Skip to Content
Streetsblog California home
Log In

Study: For Nearly Half of Drivers, Threat of Police Enforcement Doesn’t Deter Texting

1:26 PM PDT on June 12, 2020

The threat of police enforcement isn't deterring dangerous drivers from texting behind the wheel, a new study shows — the latest reminder that cops don't necessarily make streets safer.

A shocking 43.7 percent of drivers who have crashed their cars in the last two years admitted to reading text messages behind the wheel, "even believing there is a risk of getting caught by police," a study from AAA revealed. A further 42.7 percent of those drivers admitted to typing text messages while driving when they suspected law enforcement officers might be watching — even though cell phone use is a contributing factor in 22 to 24 percent of fatal car crashes.

It's a sobering statistic, especially when seen through the lens of our ongoing national conversation about police brutality and racial disparities in violent enforcement measures towards blacks. Many proponents of defunding local police forces argue that in addition to officers brutalizing blacks, police enforcement isn't even an effective deterrent to many forms of violent crime that disproportionately impact communities of color — and stats like these suggest that violent traffic crimes may be among them.

Nationally, funding for police departments has nearly tripled since 1977, but traffic fatalities have fallen just 23 percent over the same period, despite officers issuing as many as 50 million traffic citations every year. Most experts attribute even that modest downturn primarily to advances in vehicle safety technology — not cop intervention.

Source: Bloomberg.
Source: Bloomberg

The threat of enforcement isn't the only thing that's failing to keep some of the most dangerous drivers from learning the error of their ways — because countless public health campaigns aimed at educating drivers about the dangers of texting behind the wheel have seemingly failed, too. A staggering 96 percent of the survey respondents reported that they knew that cell phone use while operating a motor vehicle is "dangerous" or "extremely dangerous" — but that didn't stop many of them from doing it.

"While drivers acknowledge that certain activities behind the wheel – like texting — are dangerous, some do them anyway,” said David Yang, executive director of the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety.

The report did not offer solutions for curbing the dangerous driving behaviors where enforcement and education have so far failed, besides a stern edict to drivers to "stay focused." (Good luck with that strategy, AAA.) But some experts believe that better safety campaigns that focus less on lectures to drivers about responsibility and more on helping people understand the psychology behind distracted driving could help — and when it doesn't, anti-texting technology must play a role.

"We’ll have to launch safety campaigns to orient us to the very idea that our minds simply don’t work the way we think they do," research psychologist Steve Casner said in an op-ed for Time magazine. "We’ll have to train parents to provide the psychological rationale behind their advice and admonitions to children. We’ll have to convince schools to teach our kids the basics of how our fallible minds work. Manufacturers of cars and phones alike will need to better foresee misuses that spring from our erroneous beliefs, and provide more detailed warnings about how things might go wrong when lockout safety features aren’t possible."

Until that happens, the least we can be do is be skeptical of the impact of an overfunded, hyper-militarzied law enforcement body on deeply dangerous and all-too-human behaviors like texting behind the wheel — especially when those same paramilitary officers pose other increasingly undeniable dangers to residents of color.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog California

Mayor Nixes LAPD Pilot to use Lassos on Metro Trains

LAPD got approval from the Police Commission to extend their BolaWrap pilot on Metro in August, but hadn't advised Metro of their plans until after the fact.

October 4, 2023

RSR Bridge Pilot Coming to an End – What’s Next?

There has been pressure from lawmakers and business groups to turn the path on the upper deck into another car lane.

October 4, 2023

Study: Remote Work Isn’t Always A Cure for America’s Driving Addiction

A lot of Americans traded long commutes for short errands during the pandemic — but whether that swap resulted in more or less driving is a consequence of policy choices.

October 4, 2023

Wednesday’s Headlines

Caltrans official demoted for fighting freeway expansion; Highway 37 expansion begins; America doesn't have to be so car-centric; More

October 4, 2023
See all posts