Skip to Content
Streetsblog California home
Streetsblog California home
Log In
Streetsblog California

State Supreme Court Reinforces Rules that Cities Must Maintain Safe Roads

When Ty Whitehead was injured in a crash caused by a pothole in Oakland, it sparked an eight-year legal battle that is still being waged.

Whitehead poses at the entrance to Malibu as part of the Aids Lifecycle Run in 2016. Image via Whitehead’s social media.

The California State Supreme Court ruled in favor of an Oakland cyclist injured on the city’s streets and clarified again that, yes, cities are responsible to maintain safe streets and can’t hide behind third-party waivers when unsafe conditions cause crashes.

In 2017, Ty Whitehead was biking on Skyline Boulevard in Oakland as part of an official training ride for the upcoming AIDS Lifecycle (Lifecycle) ride between San Francisco and Santa Monica. Whitehead was an experienced bicyclist who had completed the 545-mile Lifecycle route in previous years, but that didn’t save him from hitting a pothole, flipping over his handlebars, and hitting his helmeted head on the sidewalk. Whitehead was in a coma for two weeks.

To add insult to injury, Oakland washed their hands of any responsibility and fought Whiteside in court when he sought damages for his injuries and reimbursement for his medical expenses. Oakland claimed a waiver he signed with Lifecycle that absolves the non-profit should an injury happen on one of their rides also absolved the city. Oakland was not party to the document. The Alameda County Superior Court agreed with the city.

“To us, that was very appalling,” said Justin Hu-Nguyen, the co-executive director of Bike East Bay of both the city’s claims and the court's ruling.

When Whitehead appealed the ruling to the State Supreme Court, Bike East Bay rallied other bicycle groups to support his legal effort. The Rahman Legal Group submitted a brief on behalf of Bike East Bay, California Bike Coalition (CalBike), and the San Francisco Bicycle Coalition (SFBike).

“We felt it was important to speak up in this case because a victory for the City of Oakland would have impacted the safety of people who get around by bike throughout California,” writes Kendra Ramsey, the executive director of CalBike.

Last week, the Supreme Court ruled that the Alameda Court erred and sent the case back to them for further deliberations. While the court ruled that a third-party waiver cannot absolve a city from its legal obligations, it did not award final judgement. The city can try a different defense in the Alameda courthouse if it chooses under the “doctrine of primary assumption of risk.” 

In plain English, the city could argue that Whitehead was participating in an activity knowing there are inherent risks and thus cannot sue for injuries caused by those risks. Oakland has not announced if they will continue to defend themselves in the lawsuit or if they will seek a settlement with Whitehead.

While the lawsuit was proceeding, the city did make a series of short-term safety fixes to Skyline Boulevard, including filling potholes last July. More permanent fixes are expected in the next two to three years, but Bike East Bay warns those improvements may be put on hold because of the city’s budget crisis.

But for now, cycling groups are celebrating what they feel is a legal wrong that has been righted.

"This ruling is a big win for people across California who bike. It's encouraging that the state Supreme Court unanimously ruled that cities cannot sidestep their obligations to safely maintain roads for all users," concludes Christopher White, executive director of SF Bike.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog California

Friday’s Headlines

Another freeway falling into the ocean?

July 25, 2025

Hit and Run Driver Kills Pedestrian in the Excelsior, More Evidence that Paint and Plastic Aren’t Enough

Killed by a hit & run driver, long outreach, and lack of real protection on another notorious street.

July 24, 2025

Metro A Line Extension to Pomona Will Open September 19

Nine new miles of light rail, four new stations - Glendora, San Dimas, La Verne, and Pomona - extending the world's longest light rail line.

July 24, 2025

Thursday’s Headlines

Hey that Stoner Park DIY crosswalk is right by my house!

July 24, 2025

What Will It Take to Automatically Brick Drivers’ Cell Phones Behind the Wheel?

The technology to stop cell phone use behind the wheel has existed for years. Why are so few drivers using it – and why aren't lawmakers making them?

July 23, 2025

CalBike Insider: Updating Bike Parking in Green Building Codes

"CalBike and 17 of our local partners submitted a letter to the California Building Standards Commission, which is updating California’s Green Building Standards Code."

July 23, 2025
See all posts