Skip to Content
Streetsblog California home
Streetsblog California home
Log In

Traffic Violence Epidemic’s Latest Victim: Alameda Co Supervisor Wilma Chan

Alameda County Supervisor Wilma Chan, 72, was crossing the street at Grand and Shoreline in Alameda Wednesday just after 8 a.m. when a motorist struck her, causing a fatal head injury.

"It’s going to be a huge loss," said Denyse Trepanier of Bike Walk Alameda, in a phone interview with Streetsblog. "Ms. Chan was killed by a driver near what has been identified as a high-injury intersection in Alameda's Vision Zero Action Plan."

"The tragic killing of Supervisor Chan marks the second year in a row that Alameda has experienced at least four traffic fatalities, over twice Alameda’s average. More people are killed and injured by people driving in Alameda than any other type of illegal activity," wrote Alameda City Councilperson John Knox White, in a text to Streetsblog. "Enough is enough!"

Alameda Police are still investigating the crash. Lieutenant Alan Kuboyama, a spokesperson for the department, told Streetsblog that the motorist, who was driving an SUV, was proceeding straight on Shoreline. From what Streetsblog could determine from an investigation of the scene and marks on the pavement, Chan was in or near the crosswalk at the time of the collision and was either propelled forward by the impact or rolled off the hood of the SUV and hit the pavement.

The SUV involved in the collision.
The SUV involved in the collision, currently in impound

Given the time of day, glare from the morning sun may have been a factor, confirmed Kuboyama. But as Streetsblog has pointed out in previous posts, if the driver was blinded by glare, the correct action is to immediately brake.

Trepanier, meanwhile, told Streetsblog that this latest tragedy is a testament to how much work there is to do make streets safer. The intersection needs raised crosswalks or a speed table and other measures to force motorists to slow down. But reducing traffic violence will require a multi-faceted approach. "Everyone’s looking for this one root cause they want to blame for not fixing - but it’s cars."

A passer-by leaves more flowers at the location of Wednesday's tragedy

In Streetsblog's view, Trepanier is absolutely right. A key and often overlooked component of traffic safety is reducing motor vehicle use--period. Our streets are like a giant game of Russian Roulette. And every tool possible has to be used to reduce the number of fatal shots. One of those has to be to make it easier to bike, walk, and use transit--and harder to drive--so fewer opportunities exist for motorists to kill vulnerable road users in the first place.

And yet, agencies such as the Alameda County Transportation Commission, on which Chan served, have continued to prioritize car speed and throughput at the expense of safe pedestrian and bicycle infrastructure. As a result, more people are forced to drive as their primary means of transportation throughout the Bay Area. More miles driven means more people killed. That's clear from the fact that when the economy is strong, more people die in crashes. When gas prices are low, more people die in crashes.

A recently completed approach to Alameda Island, which is to the right, designed by Alameda County. Infrastructure such as this is hostile to cycling and walking and encourages more traffic violence

Even now, work continues in Alameda County on adding car throughput to the Webster and Posey tubes while a project to build a bike and pedestrian bridge between Oakland and Western Alameda languishes. Messed up priorities such as that bring more cars to Alameda. More people die as a result.

"We have to follow the example of Mayor Anne Hidalgo of Paris," said Trepanier, referring to recent, aggressive moves in Paris to close more and more lanes to vehicles and create safe space for walking and biking. "Traffic safety is a Gordian Knot that we must unravel."

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog California

Automated Enforcement Coming Soon to a Bus Lane Near You

Metro is already installing on-bus cameras. Soon comes testing, outreach, then warning tickets.

April 19, 2024

Friday’s Headlines

SF plans street redesign at crash site; Santa Cruz commission still supports plan to have both trail and rail; State budget includes subsidies for fossil fuel industry; Unhoused camping; More

April 19, 2024

Legislators Tackle AV, School Zone Safety

Are AVs freight trucks ready to be deployed on California roads with no one in them?

April 17, 2024

Metro Looks to Approve Torrance C Line Extension Alignment

Selecting the relatively low-cost hybrid alternative should help the oft-delayed South Bay C Line extension move a step closer to reality

April 17, 2024
See all posts