Skip to Content
Streetsblog California home
Streetsblog California home
Log In

Note: GJEL Accident Attorneys regularly sponsors coverage on Streetsblog San Francisco and Streetsblog California. Unless noted in the story, GJEL Accident Attorneys is not consulted for the content or editorial direction of the sponsored content.

In response to continued parochialism from transit directors, the group "Seamless Bay Area" has launched a petition to create a single, rational, integrated fare structure for the Bay Area's 27 different transit systems.

From the advocacy group's petition page:

Public transit must work as one seamless, connected, and convenient network across the San Francisco Bay Area and beyond. Getting around on transit must be as fast and easy as driving a car. Coordinated bus, rail, and ferry routes and schedules should encourage effortless transfers. Consistent and clear customer information, branding, and maps should make using transit simple and dignified.

"We launched the petition both to build support for fare integration, but also for broader reforms that may be introduced over the next year, particularly as discussions over a future 'mega' transportation funding measure continue," wrote Seamless's co-founder Ian Griffiths in a direct message to Streetsblog.

The petition, which was launched just before the Independence Day holiday break, will be sent to a range of lawmakers, from state Assemblymember Phil Ting to state Senator Jim Beall, BART board chair Bevan Dufty, and the SFMTA's Malcolm Heinicke.

Hail a Lyft or an Uber, and you pay one fare, with one app, and one rational, distance-base charge to get from your origin to your destination. But take transit from A to B, and you're faced with a disassociated, irrational, and confusing bunch of charges, depending on whether you use AC Transit, Muni, BART, or any of the other 27 systems. This has long been the bane of Bay Area transit advocates--and Seamless wants to fix it.

A map of the London transit system, with its fare zones, all integrated under a single fare umbrella. Image: TfL
A map of the London transit system, with its fare zones, all integrated under a single fare umbrella. Image: TfL
false

The group wants Bay Area transit fares to work as they do in Toronto, London, Switzerland, and elsewhere. In those places, an umbrella agency collects fares in a rational, integrated way, so from a rider perspective it doesn't matter if they're taking an equivalent of Caltrain, or SamTrans, or VTA--fares, over the same distance, are the same, and paying them is simple. Riders, in fact, don't even always know they're transferring between systems. "The Seamless Transit Principles have been developed to guide local, regional, and state decision-makers to pursue a seamlessly integrated, world-class transit system that works for people," writes the group on its page.

Just last month at the nine-member Clipper Executive Board of the Metropolitan Transportation Commission, managers of Caltrain, BART, AC Transit, VTA, and other agencies voted not to even study fare integration, despite the pleas of transit advocates from Seamless, SPUR, and Friends of Caltrain. This makes statewide efforts to integrate transit fare systems look like a mere academic exercise.

A few days after the vote, Streetsblog spoke with MTC chief Therese McMillan about the decision, and she insisted that fare integration is "not going to be put aside." She pointing out that the next time the issue will be considered by the MTC, in the fall, there will be different people voting and heading up key transit agencies, including at BART and SFMTA.

The transit advocates hope that, with this petition, those new managers will be encouraged to take a more regional perspective.

"The petition has been in the works since before the Clipper vote but the timing has worked out well such that we can now use the petition to channel people’s anger about that event into action, and hopefully get that study back on track," wrote Griffiths.

Read more about the group's Seamless Transit Principles. And be sure to sign the petition.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog California

Tuesday’s Headlines

A lot of CA v Trump news, but there's plenty going on in cities (and ports!) throughout the state.

September 23, 2025

Our Streets Look Like War Zones — But What if They Were ‘Sites of Peacebuilding’ Instead?

A peace and conflict studies scholar weighs in on what car culture has in common with global conflicts — and why we need to confront violence on our roads if we want to end violence around the globe.

September 23, 2025

There’s Good Science Behind the Human Craving for Livable Streets

It's time to understanding the science of pedestrian-friendly cities. Or, why streets should be designed like gardens.

September 22, 2025

Caltrain Celebrates Electric Train Anniversary as Gov. Signs Bill for More

Gavin Newsom's signature on "Cap-and-Invest" means there will be even more rail electrification in the future.

September 22, 2025

StreetSmart Ep10: Zack Deutsch-Gross and the 2025 Legislative Session

A look back at the session, and forward at the state of advocacy.

September 22, 2025

Eyes on the Street: Culver City Robertson Improvements Under Construction

Culver City is nearly done transforming one long block of Robertson Boulevard to be a safe bike/walk/transit first/last mile connection to the Metro E Line Station.

September 22, 2025
See all posts