Skip to Content
Streetsblog California home
Streetsblog California home
Log In
Streetsblog USA

Compelling Evidence That Wider Lanes Make City Streets More Dangerous

The rate of side impact crashes is lowest on urban streets with lanes about 10.5 feet wide -- much narrower than the standard 12 feet. Graph: Dewan Karim
false

The "forgiving highway" approach to traffic engineering holds that wider is safer when it comes to street design. After decades of adherence to these standards, American cities are now criss-crossed by streets with 12-foot wide lanes. As Walkable City author Jeff Speck argued in CityLab last year, this is actually terrible for public safety and the pedestrian environment.

A new study reinforces the argument that cities need to reconsider lane widths and redesign streets accordingly. In a paper to be presented at the Canadian Institute of Traffic Engineers annual conference, author Dewan Masud Karim presents hard evidence that wider lanes increase risk on city streets.

Karim conducted a wide-ranging review of existing research as well as an examination of crash databases in two cities, taking into consideration 190 randomly selected intersections in Tokyo and 70 in Toronto.

Looking at the crash databases, Karim found that collision rates escalate as lane widths exceed about 10.5 feet.

Roads with the widest lanes -- 12 feet or wider -- were associated with greater crash rates and higher impact speeds. Karim also found that crash rates rise as lanes become narrower than about 10 feet, though this does not take impact speeds and crash severity into account. He concluded that there is a sweet spot for lane widths on city streets, between about 10 and 10.5 feet.

In Toronto, where traffic lanes are typically wider than in Tokyo, the average crash impact speed is also 34 percent higher, Karim found, suggesting that wider lanes not only result in more crashes but in more severe crashes.

The "inevitable statistical outcome" of the "wider-is-safer approach is loss of precious life, particularly by vulnerable citizens," Karim concluded.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog California

Friday’s Headlines

More on the Governor's budget, More on Bike Day, More on Olympics, and more....

May 16, 2025

First Reviews of the Governor’s Revised Budget Are In

It's a split decision, but when it comes to transportation reformers the reviews are mostly negative.

May 15, 2025

‘Bike to Wherever Day’ Rallies on Both Sides of the Bay

Advocates celebrate progress—and call bullsh*t on a few things...

May 15, 2025

Talking Headways Podcast: Running to Work

Bridge engineer Daniel Baxter on his almost daily running commute in Minneapolis.

May 15, 2025

Thursday’s Headlines

Happy Budget to Work Day...errr Bike to Anywhere Day!

May 15, 2025
See all posts