“Clean Air” Assemblymember Friedman Still Pushing Diesel Instead of Bullet Trains in Central Valley

The Central Valley has the highest rates of childhood asthma in the country. Despite this, the Assembly Transportation Committee, headed by Laura Friedman (D-Glendale), has spiked a bill that would ban diesel locomotives on California's High-Speed Rail tracks.

“For the second year in a row, the Assembly Transportation Committee has refused to hear my bill, which would ban the High-Speed Rail Authority from operating diesel engines in the most polluted air basin in the country," wrote Assemblymember Adam Gray, whose district runs from Merced to Modesto, in an email to Streetsblog. "Greedy LA politicians see an opportunity to take billions of dollars intended for investment in the San Joaquin Valley and redirect it to their own pet projects down south."

The state is currently constructing a 117-mile line in the Central Valley that will one day be the spine of an electrified, statewide bullet train system. Stringing electrified wire over the tracks is necessary to permit speeds in the 200 m.p.h. range and is an integral aspect of bullet-train systems throughout the world. Electrification, obviously, also eliminates emissions. However, as previously reported, Assemblymember Friedman, along with Assemblymembers Anthony Rendon and Luz Rivas, want to divert the $4.8 billion budgeted for high-speed rail electrification to Metrolink, LA's diesel-powered commuter rail system. Unlike Caltrain in the Bay Area, which is in the middle of a $2 billion project to electrify its entire system with overhead wire, Metrolink has no real electrification plans of its own (although it did produce a video about an experimental hydrogen-electric train it hopes to test on the San Bernardino line).

Under the proposal of the L.A. politicians, not only would there be more diesels running in Southern California, but conventional, diesel-hauled Amtrak trains would use the tracks in the Central Valley for the foreseeable future as well.

Yes - Metrolink needs upgrades to better serve Southern California counties. Metrolink should be frequent and electric. But if Friedman is serious about investing in Metrolink, why not look to shift funds away from more polluting modes - like, say, driving? Freeway-widening projects continue in earnest in Southern California, with plenty of state transportation funding. Friedman should look to shift California's copious highway money toward rail. How about S.B. 1 programs, such as Solutions for Congested Corridors Program (SCCP) and Trade Corridor Enhancement Program (TCEP)? What about shifting money from highway expansion to rail? Now you're talking real money - and real environmental benefits.

"These same politicians claim to champion the interests of vulnerable and underserved populations while calling themselves ‘Clean Air Champions.’ We have a word for that where I come from, and it comes out the back of a bull,” said Gray.

Gray added that:

Via Twitter, Assemblymember Laura Friedman characterized the proposed Central Valley diesel ban as "a bad bill authored by a legislator who exactly no one considers to be an environmentalist."

Last week she posted that she finds it "troubling that emissions in the transportation sector only continue to increase."

Note the California High-speed Rail Authority will submit the final 2020 business plan, which includes electrification, for approval to the Legislature on or before April 15.