Skip to Content
Streetsblog California home
Streetsblog California home
Log In

Note: GJEL Accident Attorneys regularly sponsors coverage on Streetsblog San Francisco and Streetsblog California. Unless noted in the story, GJEL Accident Attorneys is not consulted for the content or editorial direction of the sponsored content.

See that drainage gutter pan to the left of the curb in the lead photo and the photo below? That's part of what qualifies as bike infrastructure on a brand new street in Oakland that will serve the Brooklyn Basin Housing development, currently under construction. That waterfront development will eventually house 3,000 people. The expectation is that many, if not most, of the new residents will get around by foot and by bike.

But if that's going to happen, first we need to stop pretending drainage channels make suitable bike lanes (even if a painted buffer is added later, which is reportedly the plan).

IMG_20180514_092637
Sorry, this is a drain pan, not a bike lane.
false
The new bridge, connecting Embarcadero to Brooklyn Basin, still has bikes riding on the exposed side of the crash barrier. Image: Bike East Bay's website
The new bridge, connecting Embarcadero to Brooklyn Basin, still has bikes riding on the exposed side of the crash barrier. Image: Bike East Bay's website
false

And in the rendering above, showing how Embacadero will cross the estuary channel, Oakland is repeating a bad design it put in place a few years ago on Lake Merritt Boulevard. The current design places the crash barrier on the right side of the bike lane instead of the left, where it could actually protect cyclists instead of just giving them something to get crushed against in a collision.

The irony is that for all intents and purposes they're already building a wonderful, truly protected, Dutch-style bike lane, that would be safe for all ages and abilities, as pictured below:

Bike East Bay's Susie Hufstader on the Embarcadero's accidental cycletrack.
Bike East Bay's Susie Hufstader on Embarcadero's accidental cycletrack.
false

Officially, that's the sidewalk, but it's doubling as a mixed-use path during the construction. The plan is to move cyclists off it once construction is finished. However, imagine if this sidewalk were painted green and made wider, or a second, completely separate pedestrian path were added to the right of it. Whether you prefer to call it a "cycletrack," "Dutch-style bike lane," or the official state "Class IV" designation, the bottom line is that such a design would create a truly safe bike space for all ages and abilities.

That's also the preferred design in the Netherlands, as seen below. The only difference would be the Dutch use red asphalt instead of green paint.

A proper cycle path in the Netherlands. Photo: Bicycle Dutch Blog
A proper cycle path in the Netherlands. Photo: Bicycle Dutch Blog
false

And if your response to this photo is "what about the driveways?" please just watch this four-minute film. (Not that there are many driveways on Oakland's Embarcadero, since the road essentially goes along the coast).

It's a cruel irony that even as cities such as Oakland struggle to retrofit streets with parking-protected bike lanes with one hand, they continue to pour concrete and adhere to these outdated designs with the other. The excuse is that some of these projects were in the pipeline years ago, so the designs are outdated, but we're just stuck with them. From Streetsblog's view, that's incredibly lame: if the designs suck, then stop the project and fix them.

The good news is change orders can happen. Bike East Bay's community organizer Susie Hufstader, who commutes on Oakland's Embardero, pointed out that the City of Oakland changed the plans on its Lakeside Drive project to include protected bike lanes. This was in large part due to pressure from Bike East Bay--and to the change in management of Oakland's new Department of Transportation.

Can another change order happen so soon? "No reason that couldn’t happen, in theory, on the Embacadero," said Dave Campbell, Advocacy Director for Bike East Bay.

Will it happen? Campbell explained that change orders can be expensive and contentious. Streetsblog has a call in to the new officials at Oakland DOT to find out what they think and will update this post if any reply. Maybe Streetsblog readers could put in a few calls and emails too.

Either way, at some point all the cities in the Bay Area just need to stop building stuff like this in the first place. We have enough bad designs to fix and retrofit already. There is no excuse for Caltrans and area DOTs to keep installing dangerous infrastructure that future generations will have to fix.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog California

Thursday’s Headlines

Train through the Altamont Pass is getting closer; Clean energy is expensive, but dirty energy will cost us a lot more; Sacramento builds a speed-charging hub; More

July 18, 2024

Encouraging Seniors to Use Active and Public Transportation

Using - and encouraging the use of - active and multimodal transport can greatly enhance people's lives, especially seniors

July 17, 2024

SFMTA Approves Merchant-Driven, ‘Holistic’ Plan for West Portal

SFMTA board again fails in its role to put transit, safety, and city wide interests above parochial politics

July 17, 2024

Study: More Evidence That Safer Streets Help Local Business

...and more insight into why the belief that they would harm business is so hard to quash.

July 17, 2024
See all posts