Skip to Content
Streetsblog California home
Log In
Streetsblog SF

Nobody Should be Surprised by BART Breakdowns

4:48 PM PDT on March 18, 2016

President Nixon and his wife Pat ride BART on opening day. Source: BART.
President Nixon rides BART on opening day. Source: BART.

For years now, civil engineers have given America's aged infrastructure a "D" grade and warned that if we don't do something soon, it's simply going to fall apart.

Guess what?

Train service between North Concord and Bay Point stations was completely shut down at the end of this week, with more misery expected. According to releases from BART, it's unknown when the delays will end. The cause: older rail cars were knocked out of service by electrical surges. Things were in such disarray this week that it made national news.

And although new cars are on the way, it won't be enough. “Our electrical system dates from the 60s and early 70s. Patching it here and there doesn't cut it anymore. We need to rip it out and install a modern electrical system,” said Nick Josefowitz, BART Board member and transportation advocate. “It's a big job - hundreds of miles of cables and third rail, dozens of substations and transformers, etc—but we have little choice.”

Clearly, Bay Area residents need to suck it up and pass the proposed $3 billion or more bond towards BART improvements. With luck, this latest round of BART problems will foster an attitudinal shift from the voters; people must connect the dots between failing infrastructure and the extra few dollars in tax they may have to pay for a functioning society. But the proposed BART bond doesn't directly address long term issues, such as a second BART tube. And that's just setting the system up for more severe failures—imagine what would happen to the Bay Area economy if the Transbay Tube were seriously damaged?

“We are now seeing more of our transportation funding going to 'fix it first,' as you see in the upcoming BART bond and 2013 Plan Bay Area, which is helpful. But we still need to find resources to add transit capacity and much needed redundancy for today's riders and tomorrow's riders,” said Ratna Amin, Transportation Policy Director for the San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association (SPUR). “The challenge before the next generation is to reform how we approach transportation funding and maintenance; reform will require both innovation and clear and honest conversations with the public and that is what you saw emerging during this week's BART Tweetstorm.”


The Tweetstorm she's referring to was set off by angry BART riders, but also by Taylor Huckaby, a Communications Officer for BART, who gave unusually candid replies, such as this one below:

When BART was new, phones looked like this. Seriously. Source: Wikimedia Commons.
This is what a telephone looked like when BART was new. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

And this isn't just a local problem. The Washington DC Metro, about the same age as BART, recently suffered a similar meltdown.

But too many people still don't get it. There was another bunch of articles attacking California's High-Speed Rail project, a statewide attempt to modernize our intercity trains, including Caltrain and Amtrak, which run on even older infrastructure than BART. The project is trying to bring California's statewide rail infrastructure up to where the Japanese were in the 1960s and the French were in the early 1980s. California's economy is handicapped by its poor infrastructure across the board, coupled by an unwillingness to invest in the future.

In the end though, whether it comes to BART, or Muni, Caltrain, or Amtrak, it's really not that complicated. If we don't fix and maintain and overhaul and upgrade transit systems, eventually they just stop working. And if there's no redundancy in the system, they stop working very, very badly. That's what happened this week on BART.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog California

Transit Month Event: Disability Access is for Everyone

BART was the first accessible transit system in the country. Advocates want Bay Area transit agencies to do better at keeping buses and trains accessible for all

September 28, 2023

Report: America’s Historic Bike Boom is Flatlining

"This growth won't continue forever without being facilitated by more infrastructure investment, [and particularly] safety infrastructure."

September 28, 2023

Thursday’s Headlines

There's new transit funding available, CA needs to access it; Bus shelters are not some optional perk; Biking is up nationwide; More

September 28, 2023

Eyes on the Station: Metro Fortified Turnstiles at MacArthur Park Station

Metro fortified turnstile entrances at MacArthur Park in order to curb fare-evading riders; sometimes this has adverse impacts on fare-paying riders

September 27, 2023
See all posts