Skip to Content
Streetsblog California home
Streetsblog California home
Log In
Bicycling

SPUR Talk: Streamlining S.F.’s Bike, Ped, & Transit Projects

Photo by Roger Rudick/ Streetsblog SF

Until recently, even something as environmentally friendly and innocuous as a bike lane project could be forced to go through a full-blown, years long "environmental" review.

"Bus Rapid Transit, light rail, pedestrian safety projects... they are inherently environmentally sustainable, but they get caught up in CEQA (the California Environmental Quality Act), said Senator Scott Wiener (S.F.), at a panel discussion at SPUR Thursday afternoon. Lawsuits and political infighting can cause the CEQA process to drag out. "Geary Bus Rapid Transit took ten years to environmentally clear."

Screenshot from 2022-03-31 12-37-38
Jason Baker, Melinda Hue, Laura Tolkoff, Bay Area Council's Gwen Litvak, and Scott Wiener during Thursday's SPUR panel
false

That's why Wiener authored S.B. 288 in 2020, to create exemptions from CEQA for transportation-related projects. That's allowed San Francisco to take huge strides forward in its efforts to get bike lanes, slow streets, and transit and pedestrian improvements in quickly.

The problem is S.B. 288 expires this year. So Wiener authored S.B. 922, to extend the exemptions through 2030 to allow SFMTA and the state's other transportation agencies to keep building.

SFMTA has already installed a slew of previously languishing projects thanks to S.B 288. "The first S.B. 288 project was in the Bayview," explained Melinda Hue, who handles environmental reviews for SFMTA. "The first project [on Evans] was a road diet, with bicycle and ped improvements."

She said the changes were based on community outreach that started in 2018 to develop a community-based transportation plan. "Being able to take advantage of 288 for this project really saved a lot of time and money," she said, adding that it helped build trust with a skeptical community that presumes the city will take an inordinate amount of time to get anything done.

Screenshot from 2022-03-31 12-55-55
false

It also let them implement bike lanes and improved crossings in the Tenderloin on Leavenworth and Golden Gate, various slow streets, and transit-only lanes in months instead of years. And, as seen in the lead image, "We also used S.B. 288 for the Central Embarcadero safety project," she added.

Another view of the Embarcadero. Photo: SFMTA
Another view of the Embarcadero. Photo: SFMTA
false

"It lets agencies focus on safety instead of litigation," explained SPUR's Laura Tolkoff, who lead the discussion. She stressed that without it--and its extension under S.B. 922--SFMTA will be forced to back off its pace of recent improvements.

But S.B. 922 is more than just an extension, explained Jason Baker of the Silicon Valley Leadership Group. He added that they learned enough from the past two years to tweak the law. "It's for inherently environmentally friendly projects. So we can help attract more riders, reduce pollution, and involve broader communities--not just those who can afford lawyers."

As Tolkoff laid out, the extension will also allow suburban areas to take advantage of the exemptions. She created the list below, with some of the additional exemptions in 922 shown in blue:

Screenshot from 2022-03-31 12-48-53
false

Forcing a bike lane to go through an exhaustive environmental review was always bizarre and counterproductive. S.B. 288 proved that exemptions from CEQA are needed and extending the law should be a no-brainer. But it also means legislators and advocates have to keep working on larger, more comprehensive CEQA reforms, so reducing emissions and improving safety on the streets isn't so arduous that it results in unnecessary misery and loss of life.

Going forward, "Let's save lives instead of doing studies," said Tolkoff.

For more events like these, visit SPUR’s events page.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog California

‘The Bike Is the Cure’: New Congressional Bike Caucus Chair Mike Thompson Reps Northern CA

Meet the incoming co-chair of the congressional bike caucus — and learn more about how he's getting other legislators riding.

April 15, 2024

Monday’s Headlines

Why drivers block sidewalks instead of parking in their garages; Santa Rose police easily nab distracted drivers; Cars are $$$$; EV owners are making electricity cheaper for everyone; More

April 15, 2024

CA High-Speed Rail Takes a Step Towards Acquiring Trains

The contract calls for two prototype trainsets for testing to be delivered by 2028, and four trainsets to be used on the "early operating segment" between Merced and Bakersfield, ready between 2030 and 2033.

April 12, 2024

Measure HLA Is Now Officially Law for L.A. City

Check the city maps to find what bus, bike, and walk improvements are coming to streets in your neighborhood

April 12, 2024
See all posts