Skip to Content
Streetsblog California home
Streetsblog California home
Log In
Streetsblog USA

Flawed Environmental Laws Threaten to Preserve Parking and Block Housing

Seattle could build many more accessory dwelling units (ADUs), but looser rules enabling their construction will be delayed by environmental review. Map: Seattle Department of Planning and Development

Seattle has a housing affordability problem, and there are serious institutional barriers to fixing it. Among the most substantial is the fact that most of the city is zoned exclusively for single-family housing.

Housing affordability advocates have been working on some common sense reforms, including one that would allow accessory dwelling units, like granny flats, in single-family neighborhoods.

But even that modest change is encountering resistance from some homeowners. And ironically they're drawing strength from the state's environmental laws.

Doug Trumm at The Urbanist reports:

The legal challenge to the ADU law was brought by Queen Anne Community Council board member and homeowner activist Marty Kaplan, who raised more than $25,000 from like-minded folks around the city to cover legal fees. (Josh Feit has good background here.) In addition to the transparency issues that ultimately seemed to tip the hearing examiner against the proposed law, Kaplan’s gripes included parking impacts and a convoluted argument that allowing one ADU and one [detached accessory dwelling unit] per lot might open up a development frenzy eating up “affordable” single-family homes in Seattle. Newsflash: single-family homes in Seattle are already not affordable to low and moderate earners.

Bizarrely, the logic of our parking industrial complex is baked into our environmental laws. Thus, preserving parking is misconstrued as an environmental asset, much to the chagrin of climate change activists who’d like to see fewer cars and fewer tailpipe and embodied car emissions rather than more.

In fact, environmentalists argue transit-rich cities like Seattle should lead in a societal transition away from car dependence. The environmental impact of a few more people parking on the street (apparently one third of ADU households if Portland is any guide) seems much less than paving more off-street parking spaces because of code requirements enabling bad environmental decisions. More parking spaces mean more impermeable surfaces, more runoff, and more induced demand for driving. There’s your environmental impact.

Elsewhere on the Network today: The Political Environment explains the push to digitally archive national climate change research now that Trump has appointed a climate science deniers to head up federal agencies. And Mobilizing the Region looks at how New Jersey Transit's funding mechanisms set it apart -- in a bad way -- among the nation's large transit agencies.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog California

Eyes on the Street: 57/60 Freeway Confluence Construction in Progress

New off-ramps have begun to sprout out of the dirt, and widening surface streets are going through the growing pains of construction closures

November 7, 2024

Sustainable Transportation Advocates React to the Trump Victory

Some sustainable transportation advocates took to social media following the election to share their fears — and hopes — for life under the next administration.

November 7, 2024

Opinion: ‘Amtrak Joe’ Has A Big Opportunity to Cement His Legacy Now

President Biden’s Bipartisan Infrastructure Law was a historic investment, but new research shows it favored highways and is raising greenhouse gas emissions. That could change during the lame duck session.

November 7, 2024

Local Results Contrast Chilling National Election

It's hard trying to find a proverbial silver lining in Tuesday's dark clouds, but here's what we've go

November 7, 2024

Thursday’s Headlines

Get ready for an uphill battle on climate, environment, rail... basically everything in CA; Nationwide transit ballot measures did well but not so much in CA; More

November 7, 2024
See all posts