TransForm/CalBike Summit Tackles Transportation Equity, Including Funding

Advocates prepare to meet with legislative staff. Photo: Melanie Curry/Streetsblog
Advocates prepare to meet with legislative staff on Advocacy Day. Photo: Melanie Curry/Streetsblog

In a wide-ranging conversation at the TransForm/CalBike Equity Summit, Malcolm Dougherty kept right on saying things that advocates are not used to hearing from the director of Caltrans. He reiterated Caltrans’ commitment to its goals of  tripling biking trips and doubling the number of walking trips in the state. He said that California is investing more in transit than it ever has before, and he even said there are freeways in the state “that may not be serving their original purpose” and maybe should be removed, using the Embarcadero Freeway in San Francisco as an example of the improvements that could bring.

Further, Dougherty proclaimed, “We should cap the 101.”

Dougherty’s comments came during a panel that included him, Kate White, Deputy Secretary for Environmental Policy and Housing Coordination at CalSTA, and Stephanie Jones of the US DOT in a conversation that acknowledged past transportation planning errors that led to divided communities and inequitable distribution of mobility benefits. They talked about funding challenges, the state transportation agency’s attempts to be more open and transparent, and what the state can do to help guide local transportation planning decisions.

The two major transportation funding streams in California are the State Highway Operation and Protection Program, or SHOPP—which focuses on safety upgrades and rehabilitation of existing roads—and the State Transportation Improvement Program, or STIP, most of which is allocated to local jurisdictions. The locals decide how to spend that money, said Dougherty, but “the state needs to provide goals and incentives for them to spend it on the right things.”

“California is focused on maintenance and ‘fix-it-first,’” said White. “The state is not building any new highways.” However, she warned, local sales tax measure plans have their own expenditure plans, and if local governments think a highway expansion will help get them the necessary two-thirds vote—or if they believe adding capacity will solve their congestion problems [see: induced demand]—then expansions will be included in the plans. “Get involved in conversations on local sales tax measures,” she said, “because that’s what’s driving highway expansion.”

Advocates recognized the efforts of allies in the state Assembly. From left: Stuart Cohen, TransForm; Genoveva Islas, CalBike; Assemblymember Richard Bloom (D-Santa Monica); Asm. Eduardo Garcia (D-Coachella); Dave Snyder, CalBike; and Asm. Chris Holden (D-Pasadena).
Advocates recognized the efforts of allies in the state Assembly. From left: Stuart Cohen, TransForm; Genoveva Islas, CalBike; Assemblymember Richard Bloom (D-Santa Monica); Asm. Eduardo Garcia (D-Coachella); Dave Snyder, CalBike; and Asm. Chris Holden (D-Pasadena).

The remarks came at the opening session of the TransForm/California Bicycle Coalition Transportation Equity Summit on Monday in Sacramento, which gathered advocates and planners to talk about gaps in equity and how to address them. It was followed by an Advocacy Day, in which groups of advocates met with legislative staff to discuss a transportation equity agenda that includes budget allocation requests and support for several bills (more on that below).

One thing became very clear at the opening panel, however: what constitutes the administration’s proposed “Low Carbon Roads” program, which under Governor Brown’s current budget proposal would be allocated  $100 million from the state’s cap-and-trade revenues, remains murky. “Any program funded by cap-and-trade,” said White, “has to, first and foremost, reduce greenhouse gases. There are only so many types of road improvements that would do that.” Dougherty pointed out that the California Air Resources Board “would have a large role in developing the program, including new guidelines for it,” and that Caltrans “will be driven by those guidelines.”

There is still no clear explanation forthcoming as to why it’s necessary to create a new program when the existing, highly competitive and underfunded Active Transportation Program has already done all that work, and is focused on the same things.

The Summit offered discussions and presentations by planners, advocates, and community organizers that covered a range of topics. Check out TransForm’s Storify here for some highlights.

Advocates Yolanda Park, Edgar Garibay, Offir, Mirta Osorio, and Elizabeth Claes meet with Senator Anthony Cannella's Legislative Director Tyler Munzing (in yellow shirt). Photo: Tony Dang/California Walks
Advocates Yolanda Park, Edgar Garibay, Offir, Mirta Osorio, and Elizabeth Claes meet with Senator Anthony Cannella’s Legislative Director Tyler Munzing (in yellow shirt). Photo: Tony Dang/California Walks

At the Advocacy Day on Tuesday, groups of advocates presented the following requests to legislative staff and told their personal stories about why these issues are important:

  • Double investment in the Active Transportation Program. Funding needed would be the same amount that the governor proposes to allocate to a “Low Carbon Roads” program. The ATP already exists and is working as it should, investing money in encouraging more trips to be taken by bike and by foot, thus increasing good health outcomes and decreasing greenhouse gas emissions.
  • Increase the amount of money going to transit operations. It is easier to find money to invest in new transit capital expenses, such as new buses and rail lines, than it is to find money to maintain, run, and increase existing services. California keeps making this mistake over and over; it’s one of the reasons our “roads are crumbling” as the headlines like to say. We shouldn’t make the same mistake with transit—California needs to invest money in running better transit operations.
  • Fund a transit pass program. This means supporting Assemblymember Chris Holden’s A.B. 2222 which would provide low-cost transit passes for students. Investing cap-and-trade revenue in transit passes for seniors and low-income people would also help make transit affordable for those who need it.
  • Mandate Complete Streets improvements on all roadway maintenance projects. This is a stated Caltrans policy, but it is not always followed. TransForm and CalBike are requesting that the legislature require that any repair, maintenance, and rehabilitation projects paid for by the state include robust consideration of all users, not just car drivers.
  • Leverage transportation investments to create jobs for vulnerable Californians. There will be investments, sooner or later, in infrastructure, and these will be opportunities to lift up communities that have been left behind by past investments. These investments should include workforce training programs and employ people from disadvantaged and low-income communities.
  • Rogue Cyclist

    The first shot is from the hostel in Sacramento. So stoked that they chose it as their rally point. It’s my favorite place to stay in town. Bike friendly too.


News from the Summit: Caltrans Launches Statewide Bike and Ped Plan

We’re still digesting all the reports and conversations that occurred at the California Bicycle Coalition’s biannual bike summit in San Diego this week. In addition to some very hard conversations about equity and diversity in bike advocacy—a subject that needs its own report—there were more planner-y presentations about on-the-ground bike issues. Caltrans was very active […]

Save the Date: CalBike Summit Coming in October

This year the California Bicycle Coalition’s Bike Summit will take place in San Diego in late October. The 2015 summit, an opportunity for advocates throughout the state to gather, share information, and learn from each other, will focus on the theme of Equity. Executive Director Dave Snyder pointed out that equity is becoming a focus […]

California Bike Summit Is Coming Soon

Time is running out to register for the California Bicycle Coalition’s annual Bicycle Summit, taking place this year in San Diego from October 25 through 28. The summit program reflects the focus on equity that emerged from the CalBike’s annual board meeting in Bakersfield this last weekend. Over forty sessions will address designing low-stress bikeway […]

CalBike Reminds Local Leaders: It’s Okay to Build Protected Bike Lanes

The California Bicycle Coalition launched an unusual campaign this week to inform local leaders that building protected bikeways is not only allowed, but encouraged. In the past designing and building separated or protected bike lanes was deemed too difficult or impossible because of Caltrans’ disapproval. The state planning department, although it doesn’t control every local […]