Santa Cruz and San Luis Obispo: New Gold-Level Bicycle Friendly Cities

SLObyLeslieBloom
A bike ride in San Luis Obispo, new Gold Level Bicycle-Friendly Community. Photo by Leslie Bloom

Two California cities—Santa Cruz and San Luis Obispo—have been newly designated as “gold-level” bicycle-friendly communities by the League of American Bicyclists. Two other California cities were added to the list as well, both earning a “bronze” level designation: Santa Rosa and Woodland.

California now has 56 bicycle-friendly communities, the most of any state in the U.S. See after the jump for the complete list. California also has the most bicycle-friendly businesses (84) and universities (14) of any state.

The bicycle-friendly designations are earned by communities that apply for it, and range from platinum at the top (there is theoretically a “diamond” designation but even top-rated Davis, California hasn’t yet reached that high) to gold, silver, bronze, and honorable mention.

The designation lasts four years, after which a community must reapply. Santa Cruz had previously earned a silver-level designation, and had fallen off the list because the city had not reapplied. So Amelia Conlon, director of Bike Santa Cruz County, put together a group of volunteers to take on the task. Hoping to achieve their previous silver-level status, they were pleased to find that instead the city moved up to gold.

Santa Cruz

Conlon credits a high bike commute mode share (ten percent of workers commute by bike in Santa Cruz) and the city’s highly successful, twice-yearly Bike to Work Day events.

“We have a really high rate of bike commuting within Santa Cruz,” she says, “and our education and encouragement programs are very, very strong—comparable to what a platinum-level city would have. There are many groups in the area doing bike safety education, including bike rodeos in schools, bike safety classes at UC Santa Cruz, and learn-to-ride classes. We also have a ticket deferral program,” in which bike riders who receive traffic tickets can reduce their find by taking a safety course through the county health services agency.

Newly completed projects and planned projects with firm funding commitments from the city council help the city’s bicycle-friendly status as well. A new multiuse path connection between downtown Santa Cruz, Live Oak, and Capitola will provide an unprecedented car-free way to get across the county by bike. And the city council has committed $1 million to fund a rail-trail project across the west side of Santa Cruz.

The city is also at work on its first active transportation plan, which will update its 2008 bike plan with “cutting edge” bike facilities that will help create a comprehensive bikeways network, according to Conlon. The old bike plan was basically a list of projects, but the update will incorporate pedestrian projects, a public outreach plan, and plans for funding and implementing the projects.

“We’re also very proud of the fact that Santa Cruz installed its first green lane treatments this year,” she added. “It signifies a willingness to embrace a new generation of bike facilities in Santa Cruz.”

San Luis Obispo

In San Luis Obispo, the other newly minted gold level bicycle-friendly community, the local bike advocacy group didn’t need to work on the application because two Cal Poly professors, Billy Riggs and Michael Boswell, were enthusiastic about taking on the task. Nevertheless, Bike SLO County has helped other communities in the county achieve bicycle-friendly status, according to executive director Dan Rivoire. Nearby Paso Robles, Morro Bay, and Arroyo Grande have all achieved bronze-level status.

Rivoire credits strong grassroots support and a good working relationship between advocates and city staff for San Luis Obispo’s gold-level status. He describes the city’s approach as “scalpel-like.” By honing in on key intersections and bikeway connections and making small fixes such as removing a stop sign or adding green-backed sharrows, engineers have been able to make big differences. He describes one intersection where a stop sign was reoriented to make a bikeway work better, and it turned out to be an even bigger benefit for people walking. “It was an awkward crossing for people trying to get downtown,” he says. “I would see parents with kids stuck there, not being able to cross, for a long time. Now it’s great to see how easy it is to cross there.”

Bike education in San Luis Obispo County. Photo: BikeSLO County
Bike education in San Luis Obispo County. Photo: BikeSLO County

“We are very pleased with the work that’s being done by city staff in pushing forward some really great, affordable changes that are improving people’s lives,” said Rivoire. “The city’s application looks good—in terms of things like miles of green lanes, for example—but also when the League asks for reviews from local advocates, they get very positive responses. Advocates really appreciate the work the city’s been doing.”

San Luis Obispo’s gold status is also due to strong bike-friendly policies. In January, the city council approved a general plan update that included using multimodal level of service, not just car delay, to analyze traffic throughout the city, with different modes prioritized along different corridors. The update also included two other key policies: goals to reach 20 percent of trips by bike, 15 percent by walking, and 15 percent by transit and carpooling by 2035, thus reducing solo driving by half; and a policy to fund transportation in proportion to those goals. That is, San Luis Obispo plans to putting twenty percent of future transportation funding towards improving bicycling, fifteen percent for walking, etc.

“We’re proud of that language,” says Rivoire. “We don’t think it exists elsewhere. It includes some leeway for one-time infrastructure projects—so it’s flexible, and that helps when the city is applying for grants. What it says is that the city should be doing everything possible to build protected bikeways and encourage everybody to ride.”

One of the reasons this new policy language made it into the general plan is that Rivoire ran for city council last year, and won. “I turned out to be the swing vote” that finally passed the general plan update after it was stuck in limbo, he says. Because of that experience, he has tried to inspire more advocacy leaders to run for office. “There should be no fear of stepping up into leadership roles, especially for advocates who have been constantly campaigning for something they’re passionate about,” he said. “You become really good at it! And you’re making the community better.”

“It’s a way to effect more powerful policy-level change which will have more impact over the long haul,” says Rivoire.

Hefty Application

The application process for bicycle-friendly status can be time consuming. A 32-page application contains more than 100 questions ranging from number of miles of bike lanes to number of active bike advocacy organizations to local road speeds to integration of bike planning in transit planning. It’s a lot of detail that can be difficult and time consuming to collect in one place, especially if that hasn’t been done before at the city level. Santa Cruz benefited from a group of dedicated volunteers, and San Luis Obispo from two enthusiastic professors—and their student assistants—at Cal Poly.

But some communities may not show up on the list even though they could probably earn a high status because they simply don’t apply (looking at you, Berkeley). This may be due to over-extended city staff, or lack of enthusiasm for earning the designation “bicycle friendly city,” or a lack of champions in or outside of city hall who are willing to take on the process.

“We try to offer as broad a menu of actions as possible,” said Nesper, “Because we want communities to get a win—to meet them where they are and figure out how can we get them to be excited about bicycling. The application is big because there are a lot of things that you can do to become bike friendly.”

But as often as he hears that the application process is a lot of work, Nesper also hears thanks from cities who benefit from it as an educational opportunity. Communities receive a “report card” that helps them see what they need to do to be more bicycle friendly (this round of report cards will become available on the League’s website next week). “The application itself is a platform for cooperation,” says Nesper. “You have to learn a lot of things about your community to complete it.”

The newest additions and renewals to California’s list of bicycle-friendly communities are:

  • Gold:
    San Luis Obispo and Santa Cruz
  • Bronze:
    Cupertino, Fresno, Santa Clarita, Santa Rosa (new), Woodland (new)
  • New Honorable Mentions:
    Carlsbad, Dublin, El Dorado Hills, Grover Beach, Novato, Oxnard, San Diego

The complete list of currently designated California Bicycle-Friendly Communities is:

  • Platinum:
    Davis
  • Gold:
    Palo Alto, San Francisco, San Luis Obispo, and Santa Cruz
  • Silver:
    Arcata, Calistoga, Chico, Claremont, Coronado, Folsom, Irvine, Long Beach, Menlo Park, Mountain View, Oakland, Presidio of San Francisco, Santa Barbara, Santa Monica
  • Bronze:
    Alameda, Arroyo Grande, Brentwood, Chula Vista, Cupertino, Eastern Placer County, Emeryville, Eureka, Fresno, Healdsburg, Huntington Beach, Los Altos, Los Angeles, Morro Bay, Napa, Oceanside, Orange County, Pleasanton, Rancho Cordova, Rancho Cucamonga, Redding, Riverside, Roseville, San Jose, Santa Clarita, Santa Clara, Santa Rosa, Sonoma, South San Francisco, Sunnyvale, Temecula, Thousand Oaks, West Sacramento, Windsor, Woodland
  • Gezellig

    Good points–after all, maybe Bronze in particular may serve to simply put an issue on a city’s radar. It very well may be the higher rankings that can foster complacency–I know some in Portland have been pushing for that city to be downgraded for this very reason:

    http://bikeportland.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/vanluelead2.jpg

    https://www.change.org/p/league-of-american-bicyclists-downgrade-portland-s-ranking-as-a-bicycle-friendly-community

    (though it looks like this year they still retained their Platinum status):

    http://bikeportland.org/2015/04/13/petition-launched-strip-portland-platinum-bike-friendly-status-139289

    This sentiment is also felt to a degree in Davis. Though I’ve never heard of a Change petition there, I know Davis Bicycles! has an ongoing “Would a Platinum Level City Do This To Its Cyclists?” campaign against a consistent pattern of lane blockages there:

    http://i1.wp.com/www.davisvanguard.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/debris-bike-lane.jpeg

    And on the infrastructure note the Beyond Platinum sentiment is also addressed in official documents:

    http://cityofdavis.org/home/showdocument?id=979

    Main Strategies to Increase Bicycling in Davis

    Davis is renowned as one of the top bicycling cities in the country. Bike trips account for roughly 20-25% of all trips in Davis, but this figure needs to grow for Davis to become a world-class bicycling city and to strive toward the city’s climate action goals. To achieve its objective for a 30% bicycle mode share by 2020, Davis must set equally ambitious goals to demonstrate that bicycling is a viable means of transportation.

    To this end, this plan assembles four main goals that dovetail with the goals and objectives outlined in the Davis General Plan and the Transportation Element:

    1) Davis will develop and maintain a community of safe, confident, and comfortable cyclists.

    2) Davis will offer a complete, seamless, and integrated bikeway network on and off street that is accessible to and comfortable for people of all ages and abilities.

    3) Davis will integrate cycling with transit options both locally and regionally.

    4) Davis will obtain Diamond Level Bicycle Friendly Community designation from the League of American Bicyclists.

    I guess it’s good that hitherto the Diamond level hasn’t been bestowed upon a US city–hopefully this keeps the Davises, Boulders and Portlands of the world aware of the fact that many systemic improvements are still left to be made to truly make low-stress, 8-to-80 bike trips in their communities viable for a majority of people.

  • Melanie Curry

    You make a good point, and the “bronze level” is indeed a low threshold. Woodland is also a good example, though, of a city that for years never did ANYTHING to encourage bikes, like so many California places. The LAB designations, if they do anything, get cities to think about something that has never been on their radar. It’s just a start.

  • Gezellig

    I sometimes wonder about these ratings. To the extent they spur communities into action, great! But I also wonder how they reinforce complacency when really a lot of these places aren’t doing anything remotely close to making 8-to-80/low-stress biking in their communities viable.

    Woodland’s a great example. I’ve spent some time there off and on over the years and not seen anything particularly noteworthy in terms of bike infrastructure there. Mostly your standard mishmash of halfhearted Second-Class (aka Caltrans Class II) conventional bike lanes–at best–and Third-Class (aka Caltrans Class III) supposed “bike friendly” streets that don’t form any cohesive whole. No protected lanes. Wide, car-centric streets with a sharrow on them.

    Just turn on the Bicycling layer on Woodland on Google Maps and notice the disjointedness of the network–huge stretches of arterials with no bike treatment whatsoever (and the ones that do have it are generally doorzone lanes). Again, no protected lanes whatsoever. Is this anything worth even mentioning, even with a “Bronze” rating?

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Bike to Work Day Part 2: Open Thread

|
New photos added! Yes, it should be every day, but it’s still fun to get out and cheer on or be cheered on in recognition of the general awesomeness of riding a bike. Also, Bike to Work Day/Week/Month is a great way to get people to try riding. People don’t want to be left out […]
STREETSBLOG LA

Family Bike Touring Along the California Coast

|
My wife Carrie, our three-year-old daughter Maeve, and I bike-toured the central California coast last week. We took an Amtrak train from Los Angeles to Salinas, then an Amtrak through-bus to Monterey. From Monterey we biked down the coast through Big Sur and to San Luis Obispo, where we caught the train back to Los […]

Fresno’s Mayoral Candidates Face Off Over Livable Streets Tomorrow

|
Fresno’s mayoral candidates will be discussing their viewpoints at “Walk & Roll” on Oct. 5 at 7 p.m. at Bitwise Industries Auditorium, 700 Van Ness Avenue in Fresno. Fresno City Councilmember Lee Brand and Fresno County Supervisor Henry Perea will answer questions about how to create more a liveable community, provide a buffet of transportation […]